Published by Cursed Crayon Club

“I Know We Broke Up for a Reason… So Why Do I Want Them Back So Bad?”

You remember the arguments.

The disappointment.

The nights you went to bed angry.

The promises that didn’t last.

You remember telling your friends:

“I’m done this time.”

And maybe you meant it.

Then a few weeks pass.

The anger gets quieter.

The loneliness gets louder.

Suddenly, you’re not remembering the relationship the same way.

You’re remembering the inside jokes.

The late-night conversations.

The way they smelled.

The restaurants you always went to.

The stupid nickname only they called you.

Now you’re checking their social media.

Wondering whether they’re dating.

Thinking about sending:

“Hey stranger…”

And eventually the thought arrives:

“Maybe we should try again.”

But before you text your ex, there’s a more important question to answer:

Why do you actually want them back?

Because missing someone and being compatible with them are not necessarily the same thing.

Let’s look at what psychology says.

Research

Breakups involve more than simply deciding not to date someone anymore.

Romantic relationships can become deeply connected to our routines, attachment systems, identities, expectations, and ideas about the future.

That’s one reason wanting an ex back can feel incredibly powerful, even when you logically remember why the relationship ended.

1. You’re Not Only Losing the Person

When a relationship ends, you may lose much more than your partner.

You can lose:

Your daily routine.

Your good-morning texts.

Your weekend plans.

Their family.

Mutual friends.

Physical affection.

Emotional support.

Shared traditions.

And perhaps most painfully…

The future you thought you were going to have.

You’re not only grieving what happened.

You may also be grieving what was supposed to happen.

Sometimes wanting an ex back is partly wanting your old life back.

2. Your Attachment Doesn’t Disappear Because the Relationship Ended

Attachment research helps explain why someone can know intellectually that a relationship is over while still feeling emotionally connected.

Your brain doesn’t necessarily receive the breakup announcement and immediately say:

“Understood. Attachment deleted.”

You may still instinctively want to tell them good news.

Reach for them when something goes wrong.

Think about them when you wake up.

Wonder what they’re doing.

That emotional bond can take time to reorganize.

Missing them doesn’t automatically mean the breakup was a mistake.

Sometimes it simply means:

You were attached.

3. Distance Can Make the Good Memories Louder

Immediately after a breakup, the painful moments may be easy to remember.

Months later?

The emotional intensity can change.

You remember the vacation.

The first date.

The jokes.

The sex.

The birthdays.

The way they looked at you when things were good.

Meanwhile, the Tuesday night argument about the same problem for the 37th time doesn’t feel quite as vivid anymore.

Human memory isn’t a perfectly objective recording of relationships.

Sometimes nostalgia edits the footage.

4. Rejection Can Make Someone Feel More Valuable

There’s another uncomfortable possibility.

Sometimes you didn’t desperately want the relationship…

Until the other person stopped wanting it.

Now they’re unavailable.

They’re not calling.

They’re not chasing.

Maybe they’re dating someone else.

Suddenly your feelings become intense.

Why?

Research on rejection and romantic attachment suggests that losing access to someone can intensify emotional focus on them.

Sometimes the desire isn’t only:

“I love them.”

It’s also:

“Why don’t they want me anymore?”

Those feelings can be difficult to separate.

5. Loneliness Can Make Familiar Love Look Better

Breakups create empty spaces.

Friday night feels different.

Your phone gets quieter.

Nobody automatically knows how your day went.

And starting over sounds exhausting.

Then your brain offers a very convenient solution:

Go back to the person who already knows you.

Familiarity can feel comforting when the alternative is uncertainty.

But comfort isn’t automatically compatibility.

Sometimes you’re missing the relationship.

Sometimes you’re missing companionship.

Those aren’t always the same thing.

6. Unfinished Business Can Keep the Relationship Mentally Open

Not every relationship ends cleanly.

Maybe you never got an explanation.

Maybe they disappeared.

Maybe you said things you regret.

Maybe they promised they’d change.

Maybe the breakup happened during a particularly difficult period.

When the ending feels unresolved, the brain can continue returning to the relationship looking for closure.

You start imagining:

“What if we tried again knowing what we know now?”

Sometimes that’s a reasonable question.

Other times it’s simply another way of keeping the door cracked open.

7. Getting Back Together Isn’t Automatically a Bad Idea

This part matters.

Not every breakup needs to remain permanent.

People grow.

Circumstances change.

Communication can improve.

Sometimes two people separate, genuinely address the problems that damaged the relationship, and later build something healthier.

But reconciliation requires more than:

“I miss you.”

The important question is whether the conditions that ended the relationship have actually changed.

If nothing changed except the loneliness…

You may simply be restarting the same relationship.

What the Studies Don’t Tell You

Research can explain attachment.

Nostalgia.

Rejection.

Loneliness.

Relationship cycling.

But research can’t answer the question you’re probably secretly asking:

“Should I text them?”

Because that depends on something much more personal.

Why did you break up?

Was there disrespect?

Dishonesty?

Different life goals?

Constant conflict?

Bad timing?

Poor communication?

Infidelity?

Or were two people simply emotionally immature at the time?

Before romanticizing the reunion…

Go back and examine the breakup.

Because sometimes the relationship ended because both people needed time to grow.

And sometimes it ended because the relationship genuinely didn’t work.

Those are very different situations.

✏️ The Cursed Crayon Club Viewpoint

The following is the opinion and interpretation of Cursed Crayon Club, not a statement of scientific fact.

Before you text your ex…

We want you to do something incredibly inconvenient.

Remember the whole relationship.

Not just the highlight reel.

Remember why you cried.

Remember what you repeatedly asked them to change.

Remember what they repeatedly asked you to change.

Remember the argument you had fifteen different ways.

Remember how you actually felt inside the relationship.

Because loneliness has terrible editing skills.

It will cut out the bullshit and leave you with a romantic trailer.

Now suddenly you’re thinking:

“Maybe they were the love of my life.”

Maybe.

But maybe you just miss Sunday mornings.

Maybe you miss having somebody.

Maybe your ego doesn’t like that they moved on.

Maybe you’re scared you’ll never feel that connected again.

Maybe you genuinely love them and the relationship deserves another conversation.

All of those possibilities can feel like:

“I want my ex back.”

They’re not all the same.

So before asking:

“How do I get my ex back?”

Ask:

“What exactly am I trying to get back?”

The person?

The relationship?

The attention?

The routine?

The validation?

The future you imagined?

Or the version of yourself you were when they loved you?

That answer matters.

Final Thoughts

Missing your ex isn’t proof that you belong together.

But it also isn’t proof that you shouldn’t.

It’s information.

Something about that relationship still matters to you.

Your job isn’t to immediately act on that feeling.

Your job is to understand it.

Because reconciliation should be based on more than missing someone.

It should be based on whether two people can build something meaningfully different from what they had before.

Otherwise…

You’re not getting your relationship back.

You’re getting your problems back too.

Relationship Reflection

Before sending that text, ask yourself:

• Why did we actually break up?
• Has the problem that ended the relationship changed?
• Do I miss this person or do I miss being in a relationship?
• Do I want them more now because they’re unavailable?
• Am I remembering the entire relationship or mostly the good parts?
• If they came back exactly as they were when we broke up, would I still want them?
• What would genuinely have to change for this relationship to work?
• Have I changed any of the behaviors I contributed to the breakup?
• Would getting them back give me peace or simply relieve today’s loneliness?

And here’s the question I’d sit with the longest:

If you knew your ex would never change another thing about themselves, would you still want them back?

If the answer changes…

You may not be missing the person who actually existed.

You may be missing the relationship you hoped they would eventually give you.

Stay Connected

📧 Join our email list to get new relationship deep dives and become part of a community that believes every relationship has a story worth understanding.

☕ Love What You’re Reading?

If this article helped you understand why you’re still thinking about your ex, consider buying Cursed Crayon Club a coffee.

Your support helps us create more research-backed relationship deep dives, ugly doodles, and relationship psychology content.

Sources & Further Reading

• Bowlby, J. (1982). Attachment and Loss: Vol. 1. Attachment. Research foundational to understanding attachment bonds and separation.
• Hazan, C., & Shaver, P. R. (1987). Romantic Love Conceptualized as an Attachment Process. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
• Dailey, R. M., Pfiester, A., Jin, B., Beck, G., & Clark, G. (2009). Research examining on-again/off-again romantic relationships and relational cycling.
• Spielmann, S. S., MacDonald, G., & Wilson, A. E. Research examining fear of being single and relationship decision-making.
• American Psychological Association — Resources concerning attachment, romantic relationships, grief, and emotional adjustment.
• National Center for Biotechnology Information — Peer-reviewed literature concerning romantic attachment, breakups, relationship dissolution, and emotional recovery.